Emerald Island Resort Kissimmee/Orlando Florida - Guest Reviews
Reviews of our privately owned BOOK-DIRECT vacation rentals
Reviews by Villa
Nice Home; [Dory's Magic]
This is my second time staying at Emerald Island. Dory's Magic 7 is a really nice house. The game room was great for the kids although the projector didn’t work but we did not call as it was nota big deal for the kids. They enjoyed the pool table and other games. The house came equipped with almost everything we needed for the week. There was ample pots and pans and utensils, a lot of towels and washcloths. The house was clean upon arrival we just needed to add our own touches. It’s really spacious as well. The grill didn’t have any propane left in it and Sri had one delivered within the half-an-hour of calling him. The hot tub didn’t get hot and the pool was down for 2-3 days. Someone was there and fixed the issues. Otherwise my family loved this house and will be happy to rent it when we go back to Orlando area in the future.
Tanya Groomes (Philadelphia, PA, United States)
Arrival Date: Jul 19, 2025
Review Date: Aug 01, 2025
Owner Response:
Thank you for your thoughtful review and for choosing to stay with us again at Emerald Island. We're so glad to hear your family enjoyed the game room, the spacious layout, and that you found the home well-equipped and clean upon arrival. It’s always great to hear that our prompt propane delivery helped enhance your stay.
We do regret that you experienced issues with the projector and wish we had known about it during your visit. Had you brought it to our attention, we would have been happy to address it right away—as we did immediately after your departure once we were made aware.
We also appreciate your patience regarding the pool and hot tub. While our maintenance team worked as quickly as possible to replace the pool filter lid that developed and issue. We understand how important these amenities are for a great vacation and truly apologize for any inconvenience caused.
Thank you again for your feedback—it helps us improve and ensures future guests have an even better experience. We hope to welcome you and your family back to Dory's Magic 7 soon!
Warm regards,
Sri
Emerald Island Rentals
Great Stay; [Dory's Magic]
Our family had a wonderful time. Love the home. Home equipped with anything you needed. The owner so courteous and caring. Will vacation there again. Love the spa and pool.
Mattie Mickler (Spartanburg, SC, USA)
Arrival Date: Jul 13, 2025
Review Date: Jul 22, 2025
Emerald Island Rentals; [Dory's Magic]
Very nice accommodations. Management very responsive. This was the 2nd time I booked this property and would definitely consider it again.
Tom Augustyn (Alpharetta, GA, USA)
Arrival Date: May 14, 2025
Review Date: May 30, 2025
Amazing House; [Dory's Magic]
This house was amazing for our group of 10 staying there. My only complaint would be there is no step to get into the hot tub, which made it difficult for my dad and grandfather to get in and out of. We also had one issue with the pool jets but Sri responded extremely fast and it was fixed immediately. I would highly recommend this house for a large group. Great service and would definitely stay there again. It's also very close to everything you need and or want.
Anastacia Brown (Niagara Falls, Ontario, Canada)
Arrival Date: Apr 26, 2025
Review Date: May 03, 2025
Owner Response:
We would like to thank Staci and her family for their stay. We appreciate their feedback. While there isn't enough "room" to put steps in the spa (as they would take up the usable space of the spa drastically), we will look in to installing handrails soon. At some of the other villas we own and rent at "Emerald Island Rentals", we have these handrails that help. Just did not realize that we didn't have them at this villa.
Great experience and exactly what I was looking for!; [Dory's Magic]
What a great home, I've been booking with Airbnb for 5 years and stay all over. This by far has to be the best place for me and my family! Everything about this home is perfect, spacious, clean, perfect for large family's or just a couple of us. Anything you want Sri had, it accommodated my 7 year old, my 17 year old and my 22 year old, so much room and things to do at the house. I don't have to look for another place as long as I go to Disney. This will be my home away from home for as long as I come to Disney. Sri even suggested that we book with him direct on Emerald Island rentals site to save on 3rd party fees, which is what we will do going forward. Anyone who stays here will be glad and NOT disappointed. Highly recommend staying at Dory's Magic!
David Schmidt (Amherst, NY, USA)
Arrival Date: Apr 17, 2025
Review Date: Apr 28, 2025
Owner Response:
We appreciate hosting David and his family, great people to deal with. I had the privilege to interact with David during their stay and he is easy to work with.
Note: This review was originally posted on a 3rd party site.
The Best time ever; [Dory's Magic]
Dory's was the perfect house for our family of 16! Not once did we ever feel crowded. Everything was comfortable. Kitchen is awesome. Pool was used from daybreak on. This was our 8 year at Emerald. Sri is the best there is!
Janice AcMoody (Union City, MI, United States)
Arrival Date: Mar 29, 2025
Review Date: Apr 07, 2025
Holiday Rental; [Dory's Magic]
The property was very clean and well maintained.All the family enjoyed the pool area and the heated pool was a bonus for the great grandchildren plus the games room. We intend to return later this year.
Raymond Fordham (Longstanton, Cambridgeshire, UK)
Arrival Date: Dec 07, 2024
Review Date: Jan 05, 2025
Wonderful villa in Emerald Island Resort; [Dory's Magic]
The communication to rent this huge house was awesome! No questions went unanswered. The house itself was huge...LOTS of bedrooms and bathrooms, enough room for our large group! The kitchen had everything we needed. The pool and deck provided a nice outside space.
Misty Russo (Jupiter, FL, USA)
Arrival Date: Oct 24, 2024
Review Date: Oct 31, 2024
Great Stay at a Great Place; [Dory's Magic]
Sri was very diligent and helpful throughout the entire process. He answered all our questions in a timely manner before we had even arrived. The villa we stayed at was clean and quiet. I could not have asked for a better vacation with my family. We will definitely be using Emerald Island Rentals whenever we visit the area. My family and I could not have had a better experience.
Jonathan Santiago (Batavia, NY, United States)
Arrival Date: Aug 03, 2024
Review Date: Aug 19, 2024
Great location; [Dory's Magic]
It was just myself and my wife staying for 10 nights and we decided on Dory's Magic due to it's location and size of outside pool area and we were not disappointed. The sun hits the pool area all day and for the time we stayed it was very peaceful. The villa could have been a little cleaner when we arrived and it had every comfort needed, the appliances are starting to look their age and could do with some replacement. But this did not effect our enjoyment. Sri was extremely quick in responding to any queries and overall it was well worth the price paid.
Garry Woodcock (Banstead, Surrey, United Kingdom)
Arrival Date: Apr 29, 2024
Review Date: May 13, 2024
Owner Response:
Thank you for letting me know about the front entrance that was needing to be tidied up. The appliances showing their age is due to the heavy usage, and they will be replaced as they present any issues. We really appreciate the feedback.
Great accommodation; [Dory's Magic]
We loved everything about Dory's Magic.
Howard Blackman (, UK)
Arrival Date: Jul 29, 2023
Review Date: Aug 20, 2023
Awesome Dory’s Magic villa; [Dory's Magic]
We were a group of 11 people at the. Residence. Had a great time. The place is spectacular. Very clean, you have everything you need. Very nice place. Very comfortable. The communication with the owner is very fluid. Highly recommend!
Maria Paula Muñoz (Santa Cruz, Bolivia)
Arrival Date: Jan 23, 2023
Review Date: Jan 27, 2023
A great place to stay; [Dory's Magic]
We stayed for a week and there was 11 of us and their was plenty of space everything was great.
Zylvia Ramos (Rockford, IL)
Arrival Date: Jan 07, 2023
Review Date: Jan 15, 0203
Beyond our expectations; [Dory's Magic]
This home was everything we wanted and more. Plenty of room for our 8 adults and 8 children. So many options of what to do. The home was clean, comfortable, and fun. Very close to all.places we went to.
Barbara Bell (Dillsburg, PA)
Arrival Date: Oct 08, 2022
Review Date: Nov 17, 2022
Dory's Magic villa; [Dory's Magic]
Had a lovely 3 week stay at Dory house. View looking over the lake was brilliant, and the extended pool area was great. Beds are nice and clean with new sheets and towels. Owner only a telephone call away and acted quickly to any of our needs. Would go back again
Paula Ball (Leicester, UK)
Arrival Date: Jul 06, 2022
Review Date: Aug 05, 2022
This villa exceeded our expectations; [Dory's Magic]
Thank you for the wonderful property. As advertised, definitely be our choice for our next vacation stay. Everything listed was as advertised/ or explained. Great destination!
Shawn Phillips (Limestone, TN)
Arrival Date: Jun 03, 2022
Review Date: Jun 22, 2022
Second year - great trip again; [Dory's Magic]
Another great vacation in Dory’s Magic. Locations is central to several attractions and many restaurants. Definitely- we’ll be back!
Kathleen McGonigle (Lakeview, MA)
Arrival Date: Mar 23, 2022
Review Date: Apr 14, 2022
Geat stay; [Dory's Magic]
We rented Dory's Magic for multiple weeks. It was great. The 7 bedrooms were perfect for family and friends that would join us for a week at a time during our stay. Sri and his management team took great care of us. I will only use Emerald Island Rentals in the future.
Frank Kehoe (Chicago, IL)
Arrival Date: Jan 15, 2022
Review Date: Feb 14, 2022
Owner Response:
We would like to thank Frank and his family for putting their trust in us and renting Dory's Magic villa. We always try our best to provide the best experience. We are glad Frank and his family had a wonderful time. We look forward to welcoming them in to one of the many rentals we have in Emerald Island Resort. Thanks again.
Wonderful break; [Dory's Magic]
We had a wonderful break in Kissimmee in Dory's Magic villa. We are on our way north now and have already started planning for next year. Everything was great, the space in the house was great.
Libby Wild (Niceville, FL)
Arrival Date: Dec 07, 2021
Review Date: Dec 26, 2021
Beautiful home!; [Dory's Magic]
Beautiful home. Love the location. Quiet area. Spacious. Owners were super nice. I had no complaints. I will return! Thank you so much!
Selena Mireles (West Palm Beach, FL)
Arrival Date: Dec 01, 2021
Review Date: Dec 07, 2021
Close to everything.; [Dory's Magic]
Great place and central of everything.
Zac Dondlinger (Amarillo, TX)
Arrival Date: Aug 07, 2021
Review Date: Aug 18, 2021
Lake view, no rear neighbors - 3 mi Disney, South pool/spa, Theater room; [Dory's Magic]
This was a nice place to stay on vacation. There was plenty of room for my large family. Any questions or needs I had were responded to and handled ASAP. We enjoyed this property.
Taneah Hackworth (Leavenworth, DE)
Arrival Date: Jul 31, 2021
Review Date: Aug 10, 2021
Owner Response:
We would like to thank Taneah for staying with us, and we are very happy she and her family enjoyed this villa very much. We would love to have her back in the future. We are always available to our guests for any of their vacationing needs.
Very nice property; [Dory's Magic]
The property is very nice. Enjoyed our stay. Two adults and three teens and we had plenty of room. The teens enjoyed the pool and the theater room, with a pool table. Had a minor glitch but the owner was quick to respond and fix the problem. I would recommend.
Clarice Yvonne Wise (Vienna, VA)
Arrival Date: Jul 31, 2021
Review Date: Aug 24, 2021
Home Away From Home; [Dory's Magic]
This home is beautiful, very spacious, clean, and most of all comfortable. Only minutes from Disney World and shopping centers. I highly recommend.
Kim Bennett (Thibodaux, LA)
Arrival Date: Jul 10, 2021
Review Date: Jul 18, 2021
Beautiful house near Orlando theme parks; [Dory's Magic]
This is a beautiful house and it was every thing I expected just minor things that had to be adjusted but the owner sent the manager and it was handled immediately. Also when you come in please make sure you have cash because you do have to purchase a gate key to get in and out of the resort. This is something that owner forgot to tell us and you have to have exact change and it is $10.00 per car and you will get it back after your stay.
Sonya Bonney-McIntosh (Southfield, MI)
Arrival Date: Jul 03, 2021
Review Date: Jul 27, 2021
Owner Response:
We are glad to hear that Sonya and her family enjoyed their stay at Dory's Magic. The Welcome Package A which we send to all guests well in advance of the arrival states "There is a $10 refundable deposit for each DAC (Dolphin Access Card) and you will need exact amount." We wish the Club House makes the change, but they do not.
Glad we found this villa; [Dory's Magic]
Emerald Island is a spectacular place, I can’t say the same of AIRBNB, which canceled my husband's reservation a day before our trip (after we made that reservation a month in advance) thanks Emerald Island team's response we kept our vacation safe!!
Yamilet Sosa (Austin, TX)
Arrival Date: Mar 11, 2021
Review Date: Mar 22, 2021
Owner Response:
We are pleased that we were able to help Yamilet in saving her family vacation. They were a pleasure to have.
Trip of a lifetime; [Dory's Magic]
Thank so much for having us last week. We loved your rental and how great you were to work with and have recommended you to many of our friends. It was a trip of a lifetime.
Michelle Velie (Ripon, WI)
Arrival Date: Mar 04, 2021
Review Date: Mar 14, 2021
Great home!; [Dory's Magic]
Dory’s Magic is a beautiful home in a great resort community. The home is just as described, very clean, and well stocked with all that you need for a comfortable stay. The resort amenities are also very well kept for beautiful scenery for walks and activities. Thank you for your hospitality. We would definitely stay here again and highly recommend this rental!
Tina McHorney (IL, USA)
Arrival Date: Jan 03, 2021
Review Date: Jan 11, 2021
Owner Response:
We thank Tina and her family for their stay and their review. We will be pleased to have these guests back in the future.
Awesome Vacation; [Dory's Magic]
This home is very beautiful. Everything was lovely and very comfortable. We were there for the Thanksgiving break. I would definitely recommend staying here if you're wanting to be comfortable and have plenty of space.
Kim Bennett (Thibodaux, LA)
Arrival Date: Nov 24, 2020
Review Date: Jan 06, 2021
Owner Response:
It was a pleasure to host Kim and her family on their 5th trip and looking forward to their next trip.
Highly Recommend; [Dory's Magic]
Location was central to all Disney and Universal attractions, yet tucked away in a high-end gated community. Sri was highly efficient, organized, and great to work with. The home itself was beautiful, with plenty of room and bed/bathroom choices for both children and adults. The lanai was especially outstanding. It rained most days during our trip, yet half of the lanai is covered so we could sit outside regardless of weather. Safety features for small children around the pool included a removable fence as well as an alarm when the sliding door to the pool is opened. Adults push a button when going in or out to deactivate the warning alarm. I would rent this home again for my family if in the Disney area.
Vicki Bierlein (Freeland, MI)
Arrival Date: Nov 07, 2020
Review Date: Nov 15, 2020
Honest Agents at Work; [Dory's Magic]
I want to praise the work of Sri, from Emerald Island Rentals. My credit card number was stolen and someone tried to use it to book a rental. Sri had the instinct that this was a scam being perpetrated and worked to track me down to let me know. How Sri was able to find me was only through sheer diligence, intelligence and perseverance. I am so grateful to Sri for caring enough to put the time and energy into helping a stranger. This is the kind of person that Emerald Island Rentals has working for them. Thank you again, Sri. May you be blessed a thousand times!
Johanna Canonica (Locust Valley, NY)
Arrival Date: Aug 10, 2020
Review Date: Aug 10, 2020
Owner Response:
We really appreciate Johanna for posting this review. She never stayed in any of our rentals (as you can see from her review). Over the years (and after getting scammed a couple of times) we have perfected the art of identifying stolen credit cards. I am glad that I was able to track Johanna's contact details to give her heads up so that she can cancel her ceredit card. I am glad everything worked out for all involved, except for the crooks who stole the credit card
Beautiful home!; [Dory's Magic]
Hello All! This home was beautiful and a perfect stay! We loved having our own pool to swim in every day. We had one minor issue with the garbage disposal and I contacted the owner and someone was there to fix it in 10 minutes! The only complaint I would have is the sliding doors is they need a better handle for opening and closing the doors. Thank you Emerald Island for the use of your Beautiful Home!
Malory Wireman (Stockbridge, MI)
Arrival Date: Feb 08, 2020
Review Date: Mar 20, 2020
Owner Response:
We appreciate these guests for renting Dory's Magic and for taking the time to review. We will look at replacing the handle for the sliding door.
Wonderful stay; [Dory's Magic]
We had a great stay at this lovely home. It accommodated well for us party of 16 including young kids who had fun in the games room. Host was very pleasant and responsive prior to our arrival. We really enjoyed our stay here and house was well kept, clean, spacious and cosy. Truly recommended. Thank you Sri for being an excellent host.
Hanifah (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia)
Arrival Date: Dec 16, 2019
Review Date: Jan 12, 2020
Owner Response:
Thank you for spending your Christmas vacation with us. We look forward to having you back.
Awesome Home; [Dory's Magic]
Thank you so much for allowing our family the chance to experience your beautiful home!! We had a wonderful time at the home and the easy drive to Disney was fantastic. The home was as described and everything was clean and in working order.
The owner was very easy to work with and we had everything we needed prior to the arrival. We will use his home and or homes when we come again.
Tracey Malooley (Terre Haute, IN)
Arrival Date: Sep 07, 2019
Review Date: Sep 16, 2019
Amazing Time; [Dory's Magic]
As always my family and I enjoyed our stay. Dory's Magic Villa was everything described in the description. Very nice and spacious villa. I highly recommend if visiting Florida definitely stay in one of the villlas at Emerald Island, I promise you won't be disappointed.
Kim Bennett (Thibodaux, LA)
Arrival Date: Aug 08, 2019
Owner Response:
As always it was a pleasure to host Kim and her family (for the third time).
Amazing Stay; [Dory's Magic]
We had an amazing time staying at Dory' Magic! The house was beautiful and clean when we arrived! We were very comfortable in the house. This house and community was so close not just to Disney, but to restaurants, grocery stores as well as souvenir shops! We will definitely be looking forward to returning and staying again!!
Anneliese Sanchez (San Antonio, TX, USA)
Arrival Date: Jul 03, 2019
Review Date: Jul 11, 2019
Amazing Stay at Dory's Magic; [Dory's Magic]
We had an amazing time staying at Dory' Magic! The house was beautiful and clean when we arrived! We were very comfortable in the house. This house and community was so close not just to Disney, but to restaurants, grocery stores as well as souvenir shops! We will definitely be looking forward to returning and staying again!!
Anneliese Sanchez (San Antonio, TX, USA)
Arrival Date: Jun 22, 2019
Review Date: Jul 03, 2019
Great home for large group!; [Dory's Magic]
I recently stayed at Dory's Magic for a family gathering and vacation. It was absolutely perfect for our group which consisted of 11 adults, 3 teens and two children under age 5. We had ample room to spread out and move about the house. Plenty of bathroom space and the patio and pool holds more people than meets the eye in pictures. We spent our time at the Disney parks and it was a very short drive to each of them. I would highly recommend this home to anyone visiting the area with a large group. The only drawback was the alarm sounding off going out the back sliding glass door. It is a law that homes will pools have one and it took our group a day or two to get the hang of remembering to press the button before going out. Just something to keep in mind if you have light sleepers or small children, as the alarm is quite loud. But definitely a wonderful home in a wonderful location!!
Darlene Bourque (, USA)
Arrival Date: Jun 11, 2019
Owner Response:
We thank these guests for renting one of our villas and their valuable feedback. As these guests mentioned, pool door alarms are mandatory per state law. The fact that the alarms were loud enough suggests that our little guests who may want to adventure in to the pool area without dis-arming the pool door alarms will be kept safe by parents who will be alerted. Pool alarms can be disabled by adults only.
Thanks for offering a great place!; [Dory's Magic]
Very nice! Great location, close to Disney. Would use again!
Luis Urrutia (Port Charlotte, FL)
Arrival Date: May 02, 2019
Amazing Vacation; [Dory's Magic]
This villa was perfect for our needs and then some! The pool area was large and had sun all day with plenty of loungers. Thank you Sri for a wonderful stay.
Dawn Litvin (Hawkesbury, Ontario, Canada)
Arrival Date: Mar 29, 2019
Wonderful villa; [Dory's Magic]
Absolutely loved the house, the pool alarm on the door did drive me a weeeee bit nutz. Lots of room and space we would certainly book this house again.
Andrea Carlson (Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta, Canada)
Arrival Date: Mar 21, 2019
Owner Response:
We would like to thank these guests for spending their vacation at Dory's Magic and glad they enjoyed the room and space of the villa. The pool door alarms are a legal and safety requirement to prevent small kids from entering the pool area unsupervised. We understand it might be an inconvenience, but a necessary one. We will be pleased to have these guests in the future, they were wonderful to work with.
Rental home assessment in Emerald Island Resort; [Dory's Magic]
We stayed a week for a family function. Our adult children and one grandchild joined us. The home was comfortable and roomy enough for all of us. The dining room was perfect for a full meal. Would definitely stay here again.
Laurie Blasing (Chilton, WI)
Arrival Date: Feb 12, 2019
Our family of 16 had a great time!; [Dory's Magic]
Our summer gathering was a lot of fun! The house was spacious and provided all that was described. Grandkids loved the pool and enjoyed the game/theatre room, as well. Assistance with internet was given quickly. Really appreciated having supplies for the baby. Thank you!
Carl Doozan (Greer, SC)
Arrival Date: Jun 18, 2018
Lovely vacation home; [Dory's Magic]
I really appreciate the owners allowing my family to stay at this lovely vacation home. I love the prompt responses from Sri, the grounds are well kept and the location was perfect.
Angela Jackson-Lopez (Florida, USA)
Arrival Date: Apr 01, 2018
Excellent Stay; [Dory's Magic]
I had 9 people with me visiting the Disney World parks between 2/22/18 and 2/25/18. First for a large group of people you can't beat the price of staying at one of these houses. This particular house had more than enough bedrooms and still cost a fraction of the cost if we booked a hotel inside of Disney. We could of easily fit 2 more families. It is conveniently located within a 10 minute drive of Disney and there are plenty of restaurants and supermarkets close by. The place itself was clean and we didn't have any issues while we were there. The place has security when entering and leaving so you know you're in good hands. The place I stayed had a pool which looked lovely, but I spent most of my times at the park. I highly recommend staying here especially if you are going to Disney with a lot of people and staying multiple days.
Andrew Gaspar (Palm Coast, FL)
Arrival Date: Mar 01, 2018
Excellent house, great vacation!; [Dory's Magic]
Excellent house, great vacation!
My family and I gathered from across the globe and all over the U.S. at this wonderful house. It was very comfortable, spacious and cozy at the same time. Very well kept and well appointed. We had a total of 10 people in our group, the house could accommodate more. Very clean! Most importantly, it was exactly as advertised.
Tizita Fekredengel (Somewhere in NY, USA)
Arrival Date: Jan 07, 2018
Owner Response:
We are pleased to know that our Dory's Magic villa served well for this family and look forward to welcoming them in the future.
Great location; [Dory's Magic]
We stayed at Sri's Place for couple of nights and we had a lot of fun time there. The place was exactly same as it looks in the pictures. It was clean and tidy and had all we needed . We love the game room and the living room area the most . Sri was quick in responding to our queries . So I would say it was great to be there . And I would definitely like to stay again there and highly recommend his place.
Sachin S (Saint Petersburg, FL)
Arrival Date: Jan 04, 2018